Assigning Short Stories vs. Novels

Having fallen in love with Janet E. Gardner’s Reading and Writing about Literature: A Portable Guide, I decided to start putting together my syllabus using this text along with my other obsession, Marvelous Transformations: An Anthology of Fairy Tales and Contemporary Critical Perspectives.  In doing so, I realized that my expectations regarding length of reading assignments differs when I’m dealing with short stories instead of novels.

I had little issue assigning readings for the novels in my femme fatale course; each class period was roughly 50 pages of reading, depending on chapter breaks.  But I think 50 pages of novel is vastly different from 50 pages of short stories, especially when those 50 pages might include 6 or more separate stories.  While I can certainly lead discussion on 50 pages of a novel in an 1.5 hour class period, I don’t think I can realistically be expected to discuss 6 different fairy tales in that same time period.  Such a class would be a whirlwind for both myself and my students.

My solution:  For this course on fairy tales, I’ve assigned significantly more “texts” but significantly fewer pages of reading.  Especially in the beginning of the semester, I’ve been careful not to assign more than about 3 stories per class period.  This does change as the semester passes, but my assumption is that by that time, class discussions will be less in-depth and more comparative, examining connections between tales more than analyzing individual tales in and of themselves.  I am still concerned, as I would hate to assign texts that we do not discuss in class (I hated when this happened as a student), and I also don’t want my class to lack in academic vigor, but I think the risk is worth the expected payoff:  An interesting and exciting class that introduces students not only to writing about fiction, but also to the vast history and varied genre of the fairy tale.


2 thoughts on “Assigning Short Stories vs. Novels

  1. Hello Shandi,

    I enjoy your informative blog posts. I found your weblog when I was looking for sample syllabi based on Marvelous Transformations. As we know, the book is too new, and few teachers might have taught it. I wonder if we could chat sometime, and share ideas about our syllabi and assignments. I am sure I would learn a lot, especially because I see that you are also writing your thesis on fairy tales. Thanks.

    Regards, Mostafa

    • Hi Mostafa!

      I would be happy to discuss teaching Marvelous Transformations with you, but I must admit that while I’ve created a syllabus/course around the anthology, I won’t have the opportunity to teach it until next summer (at the earliest); I was lucky to receive two fellowships so that I can focus on writing/completing my dissertation in the next year. So basically, I’m not sure how much help I’ll actually be. 🙂 You can email me at shandi(dot)wagner(at)wayne(dot)edu if you’d like.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s